On this week’s feedback replace, readers are discussing Danish studio BIG’s design for a luxurious residential constructing with cascading terraces, which can kind a part of the Ellinikon metropolis masterplan close to Athens.

Named Park Rise, the constructing will comprise 88 flats stacked in a staggering association of two gently curving wings, the tallest of which can rise to 50 metres.

“Feels prefer it’s geared toward Instagram”

Readers had been largely unimpressed. “Why do most of Bjarke Ingels’ initiatives really feel like fashion over substance?” requested Alfred Hitchcock. “Simply appears like shape-making – this isn’t structure”, they wrote. “It is all a bit superficial and feels prefer it’s geared toward Instagram.”

Nonetheless, Franky 4 fingers recommended that BIG’s design strategy was based mostly on equality for residents. “There is not a category of ‘haves’ with out of doors terraces and daylight and a category of ‘have nots’ that reside in shadows with out an operable window,” they argued.

Commenter MKE Tom may admire each side of the argument. “If we’re critiquing this challenge on its uniqueness and newness, it falls brief,” they wrote.

However alternatively, “whether it is based mostly on the builders transient to make them as a lot cash as doable by offering views and balconies, then they’ve performed a very good job”, MKE Tom added. Nonetheless, they made their stance clear by including “do I prefer it? No.”

What do you consider BIG’s design? Be part of the dialogue ›

“Voluminous and stuffed with pure mild” 

Readers had been stuffed with reward for a low-energy London residence designed by native structure studio Hayhurst and Co that went on to be named RIBA’s Home of the Yr.

“Voluminous and stuffed with pure mild,” wrote JZ. “Nice palette supplies and colours,” they added.

For Marius, the challenge was “very properly performed – a grand place with none ostentation”, whereas Don Bronkema thought it was “praiseworthy – particularly the inexperienced chroma”.

In the meantime, Alfred Hitchcock referred to as it “extremely commendable” however did suppose it may have been “a bit extra cosy” and that “elements of it look fairly flimsy and roughly made”.

Are you a fan? Be part of the dialogue ›

“Nice in Vegas, not in London” 

A narrative sparking debate within the feedback part this week was the information that Michael Gove is believed to be contemplating calling within the planning utility for the Populous-designed MSG Sphere in Stratford after Sadiq Khan blocked it earlier this month.

The planning utility had been blocked by Khan over fears the venue would trigger “unacceptable hurt to a whole bunch of residents”, his spokesperson informed Dezeen.

Commenters had been cut up of their reactions. Zea Newland was baffled by the information. “Locals hate it, consultants suggest rejecting the challenge, and the mayor complied with skilled opinion however Michael Gove must have the final phrase? What’s in it for him?” they puzzled.

Different commenters responded with some potential incentives. “Evil” wrote Nimmo, “cash” recommended BardofAvon, “and energy” added LNDCNTMPRY.

Prado Sellinder thought “this type of factor is nice in Vegas however not in a metropolis like London” and requested “are you able to think about this in Paris? Ha.”

There was additionally concern for the affect on Stratford locals. “The globe is metres away from flats,” wrote Octavia. “The folks of Stratford will bear the price of this growth, with out reaping any of the advantages,” they added.

Nonetheless, some readers had been in assist of Gove’s determination. Recce Chadwick wrote “I hope he does override it and it will get constructed”. They continued “I have to say the UK public is extraordinarily depressing and at all times complaining about something new”.

To construct or to not construct? Be part of the dialogue ›

Feedback Replace

Dezeen is the world’s most commented structure and design journal, receiving hundreds of feedback every month from readers. Maintain updated on the most recent discussions on our feedback web page and subscribe to our weekly Debate e-newsletter, the place we function the very best reader feedback from tales within the final seven days.