On this week’s feedback replace, readers are discussing information that structure studio BIG has accomplished its first supertall skyscraper in New York Metropolis and debating a minimalist pink home in Mexico by César Béjar Studio.
Known as The Spiral, BIG’s newest accomplished mission in New York reaches 314 metres (1,031 toes), making it a supertall skyscraper.
Situated alongside the Excessive Line, the 66-storey constructing will get its moniker from a sequence of stepped terraces wrapped round its exterior.
“There’s one thing really cynical about this work”
Dezen readers had been fast to offer their opinions concerning the mission within the feedback part.
“Simply what town wants: extra unused workplace house throughout record-low occupancy charges,” wrote BillH11103. “In the meantime, nobody can afford to dwell within the metropolis anymore. Good!”
“There’s one thing really cynical about this work, IMHO,” commented Frank. “Bjarke continues to toss out this 30-second, back-of-a-napkin, copy-paste-array diagram stuff and folks hold shopping for it.”
In a remark that was upvoted 10 instances, Jacob Volanski wrote “for a agency that prides itself on its ‘environmentally responsive’ structure, this glass monolith with some greenwashed terraces is a significant disappointment”.
Nonetheless, commenter Hmm was pleasantly stunned by the completed mission.”This didn’t look good within the renders – it appeared like simply one other bland and uninspired Lego tower attempting too arduous to be cool,” they recalled.
“However I feel it turned out rather well. The proportions work, the detailing appears to be on level and matches in slightly effectively – fairly restrained with out foolish gimmicks,” they added.
Do you want the most recent mission from BIG? Be part of the dialogue ›
“The right pink”
One other mission that bought readers speaking this week was César Béjar Studio’s minimalist pink home sandwiched between two buildings in Culiacán, Mexico.
Some Dezeen readers had been gained over by the color scheme.
Edward Sheng discovered the “white inside calm” and Ken Steffes described the home exterior as “the right pink.” However not all commenters had been in settlement.
“I really like the minimalism of the outside,” wrote Milton Welch. Nonetheless, the “interiors seem a bit hazy and claustrophobic attributable to colored daylight coming by means of the tinted glass and diminishing the advantages of the white interiors”, they added.
Puzzello acknowledged “I couldn’t dwell in a home with no visible relationship to the outside from the inside”.
JZ chimed in, writing “I am all the time captivated by the best way mild may be manipulated, however I agree with you. Emotionally, I must see some blue sky, maybe some clouds and a few inexperienced.”
Calming or claustrophobic? Be part of the dialogue ›
“I really like when one thing is so good that I am mad it wasn’t my concept”
Additionally on commenters radar’s this week was the story that Canadian designer Omer Arbel has created a house in British Columbia with expressive pillars made out of concrete poured into material.
The columns run by means of the home, with some approaching 10 metres (32 toes) tall, fluted on the base earlier than extending upwards into an expansive “lilypad” form.
Mark Zudini was impressed. “Love the areas and lightweight – general, inspiring,” they wrote.
In the identical boat was Rob Rohena. “Wow. Stunning. I really like when one thing is so good that I am mad it wasn’t my concept.”
Nonetheless, another readers weren’t so fast to rejoice the mission.
Jb reckoned that “the ‘expressive pillars’ are enjoyable and intriguing however they conflict with the dour, modernist aesthetic.”
George Panagos was much less forgiving, writing “effectively, that is a complete lot of concrete for a totally claustrophobic and unattractive bunch of pillars.”
Which aspect are you on? Be part of the dialogue ›
Feedback replace
Dezeen is the world’s most commented structure and design journal, receiving 1000’s of feedback every month from readers. Preserve updated on the most recent discussions on our feedback web page and subscribe to our weekly Debate publication, the place we function the most effective reader feedback from tales within the final seven days.
